Week 5 : Synthesis and Evaluation

Personally, I found this week quite difficult as I feel I am much better at breaking down sources finely than combining them to formulate and create fuller understanding. After tackling this task this week I definitely realise why this skill is such a valued quality seeing as it is hard to really grasp an understanding as to what is involved in synthesis and evaluation, but nonetheless most certainly it will be a key ability that will be needed as I continue through my education. We were asked to work in groups of three this week and create a short video reflecting on and synthesising our ideas on the chicken and the egg. I believe we managed to be co-operative and each took a different section to do, which was decided quite easily, which made the task easier to tackle. I found that I was unable to do a video as the technology I had did not permit me to film a video or at least add a commentary over some images. Despite being fraught with technical difficulties, I was able to create a powerpoint online to add to the video, to explore the responses to the dilemma and draw from various other reading and resources I had at my disposal. I think it was much more useful that we each had a specific section to do as we could focus much more individually on our areas, before coming together to gather all our ideas to create the video.
For my section I used an online powerpoint maker which cycled around the arguments and then came to a general statement which led to the conclusion provided by another member of my group. I combined ideas from the original article and then added to their ideas from other articles I had read and other websites that debated the topic. This weeks task was quite hard as it involved mixing some of the skills we already had and then being able to implement them as well as being able to present your findings, all the more collaborating as a group as well.
I found working in a group particularly useful this week as it is much easier to start once someone gets the ball rolling. We each managed to choose a section without any disputes which meant we could get started without too much worry on our own little bit. I think it was good that we just each got a specific part to produce in the assignment as it is much easy to work within constraints and knowing exactly what we needed to have in our sections than if what we had to do was ambiguous. It also means that hopefully the parts that we each bring to the assignment will not be too repetitive and provide a broader understanding.


2 thoughts on “Week 5 : Synthesis and Evaluation

  1. I really enjoyed the video and felt that between the three of you, you were able to draw together a range of ideas and responses to the dilema of the chicken and the egg. The intro was strong establishing the focus of the video. The middle section which I am aware you created demonstrated a detailed understanding. I think it could have been improved by hearing you discuss it rather than simply presenting the slides. Nevertheless, you got the content across and levelled up in skills at the same time. #winning.

    The end of the video placed the topic in a wider context showing that it is part of a bigger idea. I particularly like Ella’s comment on it being one of many paradoxes within the world. Moreover, it is evident from the completed film that even given some technical challenges with producing video and sharing it online, that you were able to collaborate even more effectively this week.

    Moreover, it is clear that while this was challenging it was also a rewarding learning experience and that, to my mind, is more important than the video itself. Not least the fact that the video exhibits evidence of synthesis and evaluation which was the main focus of the week. The video was ultimately a means by which to force you into drilling down on your critical thinking skills.

    *Please add a link to the video into your post.

  2. My group did the same as yours in dividing up into sections. I was not part of the decision making process but I didn’t mind. Having a section “assigned” to me made things much easier. Like you wrote, “It is much easy to work within constraints…” I was worrying about how to start but once I was assigned my part, I knew exactly what to do.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s